Showing posts with label New Hanover Town Center. Show all posts
Showing posts with label New Hanover Town Center. Show all posts

Friday, March 6, 2020

Town Center Project Once Again Takes Center Stage



As is so often the case these days at 2943 N. Charlotte St. when township officials get together to do the township's business, discussion turns to development issues -- the New Hanover Town Center in particular.

For the two people in town unaware of this project, the  Town Center is proposed on 209 acres bounded by Swamp Pike in the north, Route 663 in the east and Township Line Road to the west.

It was first proposed in 2015, under zoning created seemingly just for this project which remains controversial to this day, and received a preliminary approval in 2017.

The project calls for the construction of 779 dwelling units, some apartments, some townhouses and some single-family homes, along with 171,000 square feet of commercial space — at least as currently proposed.

They were in front of the supervisors last night for what had the potential to be a quick technical issue which, township solicitor Andrew Bellwoar suggested needed no action.

He said he interpreted the municipalities planning code, which governs development, to mean an April 22 deadline for a decision was meaningless because the project is now under review by the township's consultants.

Bellwoar also indicated that a meeting between the developer, staff and two supervisors had provided a framework to move forward.

But Marc Jonas, solicitor for the developer, had to have the last word and in what he said was an effort to be clear, proceeded to spark a conversation which turned argumentative and Jonas taking shots at Township Manager Jamie Gwynn.

Last month, Grynn reviewed for the supervisors all the ways in which the project has morphed over
The proposed New Hanover Town Center is located along
Route 73 to the north, Route 663 to the east and Township
Line Road to the west.
the years, the ups and downs of residential versus commercial, illustrating for the supervisors the maze that the township's consultants must navigate in trying to give a meaningful review.

"And this is where we start to go backwards," Jonas said as Gwynn began to push for the developer, R.P. Wynestone, to develop the project in accord with current, more stringent ordinances, instead of those in place in 2005 when the application was first made.

"Every time he starts to act like a lawyer, he sets us back," Jonas said, adding if Bellwoar continued to let Gwynn take this line of questioning "we're going to end up in litigation."

But at least two other township supervisors, Ross Snook and Kurt Zebrowski, said they too would like Wynestone to develop the property under current ordinances, something Jonas said would not happen.

"It's ridiculous," he said.

What's ridiculous, said resident Ben Lanyon, is building 779 new homes in a town already bursting at the seams with housing.

"Since I moved to this township, I have not spoken with a single person who thinks its a good idea to build 700-plus new houses here," Lanyon told the supervisors.

Supervisors Chairman Charles D. Garner Jr. did not disagree.

"Looking back 15 years, the supervisors at the time may have welcomed developers, did favors for developers and it was easy to get projects through," he said, adding, "and without that some of us might not live here."

"At some point, someone sitting up here must have thought it was a good idea to put a town in the middle of this township," said Garner. "And this is a big project and there are a lot of outstanding issues."

Garner said during a meeting between the developer, township staff and consultants and two supervisors, one of whom was him, he raised a number of those concerns, which he also shared Thursday night.

"The original plan had more commercial and office square footage, but the plan we have now has more residential. I think New Hanover has enough residential," Garner said. 

He also said be believes Township Line Road "should be totally improved and upgraded" and added that given the problems New Hanover continues to have with stormwater, that he hopes R.P. Wynestone will agree to apply the current stormwater ordinance to the plan."

He urged the township's traffic, planning and engineering consultants "to identify big issues, big picture items, and bring them to our attention."

As an example, Garner noted that rather than wait until the end of the process, that Montgomery County and PennDOT should be made aware now of the township's traffic concerns on Route 73 and Routes 663, which are county and state roads respectively, so they can be taken into account when its time for the developer to pull road permits.

In other matters, approved a new three-year contract for Gwynn, who announced that he, his wife and his baby girl are planning to move into the township. We'll have more on that once I get a copy of his new contract.

The supervisors also voted 3-2 to hire Alloy 5 to begin drawing up concept plans for new administrative and police township buildings.

Thursday, January 23, 2020

I'm No Longer Meeting You Halfway

Norman Rockwell's famed painting,
'Freedom of Speech' depicts that speech
happening at a town meeting.
Perhaps the most important, and least appealing aspect of municipal government is the much-maligned public meeting.

They are almost always in the evening, when all of the good TV shows are on, and it can be hard to navigate the language and procedures to get a feel for what's being accomplished -- or not accomplished.

And let's face it, people in the audience, and on the dias, have been known to drone on at public meetings.

That's where your local news sources comes in. We usually have a fair bit of experience in that department.

In my case, it's more than 30 years and, remember, I'm being paid to be there -- at least for now..

The public meeting is the place where elected officials, and the paid staff, interact with and are, to some extent, accountable to the people who elected them and pay their salaries.

The public meeting is where those things most likely to affect your life on a daily basis -- things like trash pick-up, water from the tap, your neighbor's noisy rooster -- can be taken up and addressed, not always to our satisfaction.

But knowing which meeting to attend, when your issue is going to come up, why a particular motion is important, can be a difficult needle to thread. After all, who wants to go to them all?

And all too often, important matters come up that were either not on the agenda, or whose importance was not clearly outlined on the agenda.

Traditionally, this is where local news has served a public purpose, paying folks like me to know what meeting is important, and to be there when the agenda looks boring but something vital comes up unexpectedly.

As I have written about here previously, and, some would argue, ad nauseum, that vital public service is being threatened by a variety of factors. Local newspapers are struggling and closing and the public they once served is less informed as a result.

That is true here in Pottstown as it is all across the country.

All of which brings me to today's point.

Thanks to government offices being closed Monday for Martin Luther King Jr. Day, Tuesday saw seven different meetings (that I know of) that should have been covered:
The Fifth Street home where an Airbnb is proposed.

  • The Pottstown Zoning Hearing Board heard testimony on a request to convert a large home on Fifth Street into an Airbnb, an application borough council opposed. I didn't go to that meeting, so I don't know yet what happened. And so, neither do most of you.
  • In the next room in borough hall, the Pottstown Borough Authority met and, according to the agenda, set the new water rates for 2020. An attachment to the agenda made it clear what they are and I have reported on it previously, but I didn't go to that meeting, so I don't know yet if anything else happened. And so, neither do most of you.
  • In Royersford, the Spring-Ford Area School Board met for a work session. One of the items was discussion of a $176 million preliminary budget for the coming school year. The board is scheduled to vote on adopting it at another meeting Monday night, during which two other municipal meetings that should be covered will take place (more on that later). I didn't go to the school board meeting Tuesday, so I don't know what was said. And so, neither do most of you.
  • In Limerick, the township supervisors met and their agenda included discussion of the construction of a new firehouse for the Linfield Fire Company. I didn't go that meeting either, so I don't know if anything happened. And so, neither do most of you.
  • The Douglass (Mont.) Township Supervisors also met Tuesday, but because they do not post their agenda online, I can't even tell you what I missed because I wasn't there. And so, neither do most of you know what happened either.
  • In Upper Pottsgrove, I've confirmed the Township Commissioners voted unanimously to advertise an ordinance to abolish the township planning commission and replace it with a planning committee. I wasn't there, so I won't have a report on that for a day or two. The final vote on whether to move ahead with it is scheduled for Feb. 3.
  • The meeting I did go to was the Phoenixville School Board, which, evidently, had a rocky start to its year. With several new board members, the video from the Jan. 13 meeting shows the board convening, heading immediately into closed-door executive session and coming out more than an hour later and immediately adjourning. Tuesday's meeting was a continuation of that meeting.

U.S. Rep. Chrissy Houlahan
Among the things discussed was the revelation that the Pennsylvania Department of Education has cited the district for disproportionately suspending students of color.

The picture is muddled and I am meeting with Superintendent Alan Fegleyy and Assistant Superintendent LeRoy Whitehead today at noon to get it sorted out before I report something incorrectly about a very important and sensitive subject.

Speaking of today, if you've read this far and you live in the 6th Congressional District, you may want to attend a meeting I will be covering. U.S. Rep. Chrissy Houlahan will be holding her 15th Town Hall meeting at the Colonial Theater on Bridge Street at 7 p.m.

As you may have read recently, in 2019, Houlahan held more town hall meetings than any other member of Pennsylvania's Congressional delegation, a report put together by CoverThis.com.

That means I will miss the Lower Pottsgrove Township Commissioners meeting tonight where the agenda indicates architects will present the latest plans for the new $8.2 million township building.

But, check out Joe Zlomek's Sanatoga Post news site. He will likely be there and have a report for you.

And when Monday rolls around, there are three meetings which should be covered. In addition to the previously mentioned Spring-Ford School Board's voting meeting, the North Coventry Township Supervisors will meet.

Last night, Chairman Jim Marks, who was at the regional planning meeting I was covering, revealed that two important officials, longtime Township Manager Kevin Hennessey and Police Chief Robert Schurr are both retiring, "so we're dealing with that."

An older version of the plan for New Hanover Town Center.
And perhaps most significantly, the New Hanover Township Supervisors and Planning Commission will conduct a joint meeting on the proposed massive New Hanover Town Center project, which includes shopping centers and more than 700 new homes.

That meeting will be held at the township recreation center, 2373 Hoffmansville Road, starting at 6:30 p.m., according to the legal notice published in The Mercury on Jan. 15.

"We're expecting a crowd," New Hanover Supervisor Kurt Zebrowsky said at last night's regional planning meeting. "It's going to be some meeting."

Don't worry, I'm not going to miss that one.

Friday, October 4, 2019

New Hanover's (Town) Center of Attention Explored

Photos by Evan Brandt
As currently proposed, the New Hanover Town Center would construct 793 homes and apartments and 170,000 square feet of commercial space on 209 acres bounded by Swamp Pike, Route 663 and Township Line Road.




A roomful of residents got the latest on the massive Town Center development proposal during last night's board of supervisors meeting.

Developers from Select Properties, doing business as Wynnestone LP, were before the board seeking clarification and guidance as they prepare their latest submission in pursuit of a preliminary site plan approval.

The project, which has been around in one form or another for 12 years or so, calls for the construction of 793 dwelling units, some apartments, some townhouses and some single family homes, along with 171,000 square feet of commercial space -- at least as currently proposed.

A near-capacity crowd listen to plans about New Hanover
Town Center project.
The New Hanover Town Center, as its officially named, has gone through numerous variations over the years. It is proposed on 209 acres bounded by Swamp Pike in the north, Route 663 in the east and Township Line Road to the west.

First up Thursday night was the question of whether the roads in the project will be private roads or public. Either way, they will have to conform to township standards, said township= traffic consultant Sandy Koza.

Supervisors Chairman Charles D. Garner Jr. said he would prefer the roads remain private, so the township does not have to maintain them, and the other supervisors agreed.

However Planning Commission Chairwoman Sue Smith warned that private roads create a problem for school buses and she did not think it would be safe to have so many potential school children trying to board the bus on such busy roads as those surrounding the project.

The question of parking on "major roads" in the project was also raised, but soon devolved into a discussion of what makes a road "major." Evidently, the engineers and the lawyers will settle that one.

Marc Jonas, the attorney representing the developers, also pointed out that during one of the projects iterations, it received preliminary approval in 2007 under a clause called a "unified development," which has since been removed from the township's ordinances.

That gives the developer certain rights, but Garner, himself a municipal solicitor, said the developers cannot "pick and choose" which parts of the township's land development ordinances it wants to use.

Perhaps most central to last night's discussion was when the project's commercial portion will be
Yellow lines separate the five proposed phases of construction.
built.

According to the phasing plan the developer has put together, the first two phases to be built would construct a total of 351 homes, as well as much of the infrastructure for the commercial portion, which includes a "big box" space for a supermarket, or similar large store.

But Benjamin Goldthorp, who represents the developer, said "market conditions" would determine when the actual commercial properties would be built.

He said market studies show that 20,000 people need to live within three to five miles of such a store in order for it to be successful. New Hanover currently has about 15,000 people, Goldthorp said.

Some of the people who will live within the new development will help boost that number, but it may be some time before the 20,000 threshold is reached.

And that would leave the township, and the Boyertown Area School District, will lots of new homes but no commercial development to boost the tax base.

When one resident asked about the impact on the schools, Jonas said the developer is only working within the zoning the township created.

But the assertion that the township drew up the zoning unassisted drew a sharp rebuke from Smith who said the previous developer, THP Properties, worked with the supervisors to draw up the zoning before going bankrupt in the recession.

Either way, "a previous board decided a town center was something we wanted in New Hanover and created ordinances to allow it and we're seeing the result of that now," said Garner.

He said the new homes being built would be on public water, not on individual wells.

Ultimately, Garner suggested and the developers agreed, to have a special joint meeting with the supervisors, planning commission and developers to work out the remaining questions -- which is primarily the matter of waivers being sought by the developers.

Then it was time for residents to have their say.

"This is supposed to be a small town, not a shopping center,"
said New Hanover resident Linda Weaver.
One resident said she had moved to New Hanover from King of Prussia, "because it was too crowded there," and worried that with all the development occurring in New Hanover, the same problem would follow her.

"If this is built, Swamp Pike will have to become a four-lane road," she predicted.

Swamp Pike resident Linda Taylor said "I can't get out of my driveway right now as it is."

"I share your concern," said Garner. "I drive on Swamp Pike all the time." Koza explained that a a traffic study will determine what road improvement are required due to the increased traffic and that as each phase of the project begins, the developers will be required to implement specific improvements.

"This is supposed to be a small town, not a shopping center," said resident Linda Weaver.

And with that, here are the Tweets from the meeting:

Friday, September 6, 2019

New Hanover Town Center Project in the Crosshairs

Aerial photos courtesy of New Hanover Township

This photo shows some of the land clearing undertaken three weeks ago at the 209-acre New Hanover Town Center project site which has raised concern among residents and officials.
It was hard to find a parking place at the New Hanover Township building Thursday night.

And it became evident the crowd was there not because there was nothing good on TV (there wasn't), but because the supervisors had an agenda item to discuss the Town Center development.
An early conceptual drawing for the Town Center project.

Proposed on 209 acres where the old New Hanover Airport used to be located, if approved, the project would add more than 700 homes and 171,000 square feet of commercial space along Swamp Pike.

But there was an audible exclamation from the crowd when Supervisors Chairman Charles D. Garner Jr. announced that, at the developer's request, the matter was pulled from the night's agenda.

That does not mean the project was not discussed.

Engineer David Leh informed the supervisors, and the crowd that remained, that three weeks ago, it was discovered that the developers had cleared a wide swath of trees and ground.

"Acres of trees were removed and acres of ground were disturbed," he said.

Here is video of the clearance taken from a drone and provided courtesy of the township:



The problem with land clearing getting started is that the project does not have final site plan approval from the township. Not even close.

The project did receive preliminary plan approval for a very different plan in 2005. The larger, more recent plan was first submitted in 2017, but it has been changed at least five times since then, according to Township Manager Jamie Gwynn.

Leh said the township inspected the work and a Notice of Violation was issued by the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection. The Montgomery County Conservation District, which oversees erosion control plans, also got involved and ordered some measures be taken to mitigate the potential damage from the clearing.
An aerial photo of tree clearing done on the site in March.

Leh said the work required by the conservation district was undertaken and the notice of violation may be revoked.

The developers have said they now intend to seek a township grading permit to continue the work, said Leh.

Just like soil stockpiling and tree removal that was undertaken in March, this work was done under the legal umbrella of the 2005 preliminary site plan approval, said Township Solicitor Andrew Bellwoar.

The grading permit will supposedly be used to construct stormwater basins on the site, that are legally "unrelated" to the eventual development.

Bellwoar told the supervisors that he warned the developers "any work done there is at developer's risk and if the final site plan approved differs in terms of the storm basins they are now installing, they will have to re do it."

Aerial photo  showing some of the tree clearing
that was discovered at the site three weeks ago.
Garner said "I know they are the property owners and they have certain rights," but he thought the township had an ordinance that would prevent clear cutting of trees or land on that scale without review and a permit from township.

If the township ordinances do not contain such provisions, perhaps it's time to change the law so that such review would be required, he said.

The item that was supposed to be discussed at last night's meeting had to do with whether the township would take dedication of the roads within the development once construct. Garner noted that request is contrary to the proposal in previous documents that indicated they will be private roads.

This aerial photo shows clearing and clearing near a wetland.
Even more complicated matters are set to be discussed at the October meeting according to Gwynn.

Garner suggested adding the matter of road dedication threatens to make the meeting unwieldy and could cause further delays.

He said the Town Center developers, with the clear-cutting, "may be acting within the law, but it seems like they're not acting in good faith with us, the way they ask us to act in good faith with them."

Resident Rusty Oister had a stronger reaction telling the board "it's begun."

He said "it seems like these developers are pushing us to the limit of the law. They do not have the township's best interests at heart. So when it comes time for them to ask for waivers and exceptions, I ask that the supervisors hold firm."

And with that, here are the Tweets from the meeting:

Friday, August 3, 2018

New Hanover Wading Through Development Tide

A developer's concept for how to fit 65 homes, 27 single homes and 38 twin homes, on property off Rhoads Road opposite Liberty Bell Drive and Courtside Avenue. The original proposal was for 39 single family homes.
Yet another housing development has reared its head among the rolling hills and dales of New Hanover Township.

It's unclear if it yet has a name, all too often in memoriam of what it destroys, but here's what we do know:

  • It proposes 65 homes, 
  • 27 of them single 
  • 38 of them twins, 
  • and the township supervisors had a decidedly lukewarm reaction to it.

Specifically, Supervisors Chairman Charles Garner said he is not fond of cul de sacs and recommended instead, a "loop road." He said he would like to see the original proposal of 39 single family homes.

Supervisor Kurt Zebrowski, who also sits on the planning commission, said the closely packed proposal did not match the arrangements of the surrounding neighborhood. "It's like you're putting a city in the middle of a suburban development," he said.

Speaking of cities, it was announced last night that the massive New Hanover Town Center project, initially proposed at 852 homes and 210,000 square feet of commercial and office space on 209 acres off route 73, may be getting a little smaller -- by 82 units.

That same project is also seeking a variance from the township's zoning hearing board, to be allowed to have 58 fewer parking spaces than the 952 the zoning ordinance requires.

Without a plan before them -- the last one was submitted in February -- "it sounds like its a cart before the horse situation," said Garner. The other supervisors agreed and voted to send the township solicitor and any other staff required to the zoning meeting in opposition to the variance request.

And then there it Trotter's Gait and its ever-energetic attorney Joe Clement, whose attempts to wrangle agreement out of the supervisors has prompted Garner to initiate something he calls "the Joe Clement Rule," which serves to ensure the minutes indicate no agreement on anything without a vote.

In fact, a court stenographer suddenly appeared when Clement took his turn before the supervisors, evidently to take minutes that are hard to misconstrue.

Specifically, Trotter's Gait calls for the construction of 29 single family homes on a 13.5-acre lot near it's sister development, Pacer's Gait, which calls for seven single family homes on six acres both off Dotterer Road.

Discussion had to do with two relatively simple matters; a storm sewer extension through wetlands, and what defines a healthy woodland and would Trotter's Gait disturb it.

Despite the apparent simplicity of the issues involved, Clement kept the discussion going for nearly 40 minutes, including naming the many members of his family who are part of the development company.

Thankfully, two additional developments items on the agenda, Hanover Green and Hanover Preserves, were removed at the beginning of the evening, so we all got home at a reasonable hour.

Without further ado, here are the Tweets from the meeting: